Sign up for a WebBoard account Sign Up Keyword Search Search Calendar Calendar More Options... Options
Chat Rooms Chat Help Help News News Log in to WebBoard Log in Not Logged in
Clubhouses Close Tree View
+ BBM Announcements (29)
+ BBM 2010 (2)
+ BBM Beta (226)
- BBM vs Other Fantasy Games (52)
-> + BBM Stats Provider Moby Duck (6) 04/02/10
-> - Why BBM Tim Neely (18) 07/29/09
-> ->Why BBM Alan Grandel 08/23/09
-> ->Why BBM The Hound 08/23/09
-> ->Why BBM U M P 08/23/09
-> ->Why BBM Alan Grandel 08/23/09
-> ->Why BBM U M P 08/23/09
-> ->Why BBM The Hound 08/23/09
-> ->Why BBM Alan Grandel 08/23/09
-> ->Why BBM Homer Simpsun 02/28/10
-> ->Why BBM Obie (The Tiger) 03/01/10
-> ->Why BBM Bean Counter 03/01/10
-> ->Why BBM Spann Brockmann 03/01/10
-> ->Why BBM Moby Duck 03/04/10
-> ->Why BBM Spann Brockmann 03/05/10
-> ->Why BBM U M P 03/05/10
-> ->Why BBM Alan Grandel 03/05/10
-> ->Why BBM Michael Fritchman 03/26/10
-> ->Why BBM Jim O'Donnell 04/02/10
-> + And Another Reason bruno   (4) 07/29/09
-> + BBM bruno   (16) 07/23/09
-> + Why? Maximus ... (8) 07/22/09
+ BBM Bar & Grill (143)
+ BBM Suggestions (1505)
+ Coaches Blog (13)
+ Coaches Corner (6)
+ Commissioner's Office (40)
+ Diamond Club Feedback (0)
+ Draft Questions (0)
+ Form Keeper Leagues (0)
+ Form Ultimate Leagues (0)
+ Form Express Leagues (0)
+ League Openings for 2010 (0)
+ Keeper Team Replacements (1)
+ The Pinetar Experience (86)
+ Leagues - AL Keeper (A-M) (63)
+ Leagues - AL Keeper (N-Z) (2)
+ Leagues - AL Ultimate (A-M) (3)
+ Leagues - AL Ultimate (N-Z) (0)
+ Leagues - AL Express (0)
+ Leagues - AL Lightning (0)
+ Leagues - NL Keeper (A-M) (31)
+ Leagues - NL Keeper (N-Z) (0)
+ Leagues - NL Ultimate (A-M) (2)
+ Leagues - NL Ultimate (N-Z) (9)
+ Leagues - NL Express (0)
+ Leagues - NL Lightning (1)
+ Leagues - All Universe Keeper (33)
+ Leagues - All Universe Ultimate (0)
+ Leagues - All Universe Express (0)
+ Leagues - All Universe Lightning (0)
+ Leagues - Winter BBM (0)
Topic
Start a new topic New Topic
 
Author Message
Tim Neely
Tim Neely
Read 2314 times

Total Messages 213

Subject:Why BBM

In my opinion, the reasons why BBM is the best fantasy baseball game is that it combines all of the following characteristics

1. BBM is a daily game not a weekly game.
2. BBM simulates a game each day in a manner that comes extremely close to how a real game is played and scored. It avoids point per category and that type of non-realistic scoring.
3. BBM requires very close attention by the owner/manager, and that attention is similar to what a real manager does (lineups, roster, etc.) As such, it satisfies the desire to manage a real team.
4. The budget aspect of BBM is truly unique. Each team has a budget and obtains/pays for players according to their auction market set values. This is probably as close to reality as possible.
5. No other game offers all of this.

Of course, improvements are always possible, but this is not the setting for those suggestions according to the instructions for this board.

- CynicalTim
"This is in no way to be misconstrued as a political statement. Any resemblance to actual political statements, living or dead, is unintentional and purely coincidental. Do not remove this disclaimer under penalty of law."


Posted: 29 Jul 2009 04:48 PM
Left Button SpacerSend user an email email|View user's profile profileRight Button Spacer
Left Button SpacerReply to this message replyRight Button Spacer
 
Alan Grandel
Alan Grandel
Read 2153 times

Total Messages 11

Subject:Why BBM

What I  like about BBM. They take your money and make you play.......Evey single year.....

"Thank ya, Thank ya very much."

The Col.


Posted: 23 Aug 2009 11:42 AM
Originally Posted: 23 Aug 2009 11:41 AM
Left Button SpacerSend user an email email|View user's profile profileRight Button Spacer
Left Button SpacerReply to this message replyRight Button Spacer
 
The Hound
The Hound
Read 2147 times

Total Messages 140

Subject:Why BBM

What I like about BBM is those that play it have class, and don't take a lot of cheap shots like 12 year olds do.


Hound


Posted: 23 Aug 2009 11:55 AM
Left Button SpacerSend user an email email|View user's profile profileRight Button Spacer
Left Button SpacerReply to this message replyRight Button Spacer
 
U M P
U M  P
Read 2139 times

Total Messages 71

Subject:Why BBM

Fool me 10 times shame on you, fool me 11 times, shame on me.

No cheap shot's. All a fact, isn't it?







Posted: 23 Aug 2009 12:13 PM
Left Button SpacerSend user an email email|View user's profile profileRight Button Spacer
Left Button SpacerReply to this message replyRight Button Spacer
 
Alan Grandel
Alan Grandel
Read 2135 times

Total Messages 11

Subject:Why BBM

Hopefully, that's 1 less whiner for next year...

"Thank ya, Thank ya very much."

The Col.


Posted: 23 Aug 2009 12:16 PM
Left Button SpacerSend user an email email|View user's profile profileRight Button Spacer
Left Button SpacerReply to this message replyRight Button Spacer
 
U M P
U M  P
Read 2132 times

Total Messages 71

Subject:Why BBM

Come on Alan, you gotta return. It will be fixed by then I bet.






Posted: 23 Aug 2009 12:18 PM
Left Button SpacerSend user an email email|View user's profile profileRight Button Spacer
Left Button SpacerReply to this message replyRight Button Spacer
 
The Hound
The Hound
Read 2131 times

Total Messages 140

Subject:Why BBM

>Fool me 10 times shame on you,
>fool me 11 times, shame on me.
>
>No cheap shot's. All a fact,
>isn't it?
>

All cheap shots in this forum. If you want to quit, please quit. I'm tired of hearing the crap. Legitimate complaints is one thing. Sabatoge is another.

Grow up.


Hound


Posted: 23 Aug 2009 12:19 PM
Left Button SpacerSend user an email email|View user's profile profileRight Button Spacer
Left Button SpacerReply to this message replyRight Button Spacer
 
Alan Grandel
Alan Grandel
Read 2128 times

Total Messages 11

Subject:Why BBM

Whiners are born that way. It won't take me 10 years to know I hate something that much.


"Thank ya, Thank ya very much."

The Col.


Posted: 23 Aug 2009 12:29 PM
Originally Posted: 23 Aug 2009 12:25 PM
Left Button SpacerSend user an email email|View user's profile profileRight Button Spacer
Left Button SpacerReply to this message replyRight Button Spacer
 
Homer Simpsun
Homer  Simpsun
Read 1657 times

Total Messages 4

Subject:Why BBM

just my two cents I got to admit that clone thing was the worst thing I ever ran into

I liked the fool me 11 times

what I don't like is trying to recruit managers.

you know if you google fantasy baseball we (bbm) show up on page nine I can't understand how we keep playing after 19 years.


Posted: 28 Feb 2010 11:31 PM
Left Button SpacerSend user an email email|View user's profile profileRight Button Spacer
Left Button SpacerReply to this message replyRight Button Spacer
 
Obie (The Tiger)
Obie (The Tiger)
Read 1621 times

Total Messages 30

Subject:Why BBM

I've played all kinds of Fantasy Baseball formats.  In my opinion, this is by far the best game available.  I understand that the interface isn't pretty and there are periodic hicups with the daily downloads for various reasons.  However, that doesn't override the fact that you have a very realistic game that provides a real challenge for those that want to truly compete in fantasy baseball.

There are a couple of leagues out there that have great draft formtats, but once the games start half the managers go robotic because it is 90% settled in the first week.  Last year, I played a couple teams in one of those leagues and won league championships by having a good draft and visiting the team once a week for less than a half hour.  In one stretch, I didn't visit the team for 3 weeks and still won my head to head matchups.  Where is the challenge in that? 

In the Pinetar BBM leagues, I know that robo managers are not going to happen.  There is  zero tolerance policy.  On top of that, these guys know baseball.  If you want to win these leagues, you have to pay attention and actually manage your team over the course of 162 actual games.  I've won in every kind of format - roto, auction, etc.  I've not yet won a BBM league.  2nd twice and 1 playoff championship, but I've never won the whole thing.  This is by far the most challenging format for true baseball enthusiasts.

I have found nothing else like BBM on the web.  Thus, I've given up on all the other formats so I can concentrate on my teams in BBM this year.

Yes - BBM is on page 9 of the fantasy baseball search results.  But, just because they haven't focused on advertising doesn't mean that the game is less attractive.  In my opinion, other formats pale in comparison.

Obie
TPE Armageddon
TPE Hyperion
TPE Chrysalis


Posted: 01 Mar 2010 09:08 AM
Left Button SpacerSend user an email email|View user's profile profileRight Button Spacer
Left Button SpacerReply to this message replyRight Button Spacer
 
Bean Counter
Bean  Counter
Read 1599 times

Total Messages 25

Subject:Why BBM

I just wish that somehow they would fix the relief pitcher "musical chairs" thing. Bid for closers and get points for a save? I don't know, been saying that for years!



Posted: 01 Mar 2010 10:16 AM
Left Button SpacerSend user an email email|View user's profile profileRight Button Spacer
Left Button SpacerReply to this message replyRight Button Spacer
 
Spann Brockmann
Spann Brockmann
Read 1580 times

Total Messages 4

Subject:Why BBM

It is as close to real baseball as you can find on the internet!! I've been a BBMer for 19 years and I love making trades. Some managers get attached to players and keep them for years (Keeper formats).  Some will trade a player just to make a trade.  Most owners are somewhere in between. 

It's the negotiation that's fun!!!  Making offers and counter-offers.  Living through the thrill of a successful trade and then seeing the results "on the field".  And entering a trade is simple and quick!

DRAGON INC


Posted: 01 Mar 2010 11:51 AM
Left Button SpacerSend user an email email|View user's profile profileRight Button Spacer
Left Button SpacerReply to this message replyRight Button Spacer
 
Moby Duck
Moby Duck
Read 1498 times

Total Messages 38

Subject:Why BBM

It's sacrilege to some, but I wish that BBM would quit using played stats from the previous night. Just throw all the stats into a pool, and pull them out randomly.

This would ELIMINATE 99% of all the hiccups.

It would also be a nice way to GET RID of the dreaded DL.

:)


Posted: 04 Mar 2010 10:01 PM
Left Button SpacerView user's profile profileRight Button Spacer
Left Button SpacerReply to this message replyRight Button Spacer
 
Spann Brockmann
Spann Brockmann
Read 1477 times

Total Messages 4

Subject:Why BBM

I love the fact that live stats are used! That and the DL make it more like real baseball!  And being like real baseball is a huge attraction.

DRAGON INC


Posted: 05 Mar 2010 05:51 AM
Left Button SpacerSend user an email email|View user's profile profileRight Button Spacer
Left Button SpacerReply to this message replyRight Button Spacer
 
U M P
U M  P
Read 1457 times

Total Messages 71

Subject:Why BBM

>It's sacrilege to some, but I
>wish that BBM would quit using
>played stats from the previous
>night. Just throw all the
>stats into a pool, and pull
>them out randomly.
>
>This would ELIMINATE 99% of
>all the hiccups.
>
>It would also be a nice way to
>GET RID of the dreaded DL.
>
>:)

No way. You'd ruin the game we love.








Posted: 05 Mar 2010 09:37 AM
Left Button SpacerSend user an email email|View user's profile profileRight Button Spacer
Left Button SpacerReply to this message replyRight Button Spacer
 
Alan Grandel
Alan Grandel
Read 1429 times

Total Messages 11

Subject:Why BBM

We can debate the DL at length, when all you guys came to the crab feast this summer. I LOVE the DL myself. Bring you bib and your wits.We can talk all night.



"Thank ya, Thank ya very much."

The Col.


Posted: 05 Mar 2010 05:07 PM
Left Button SpacerSend user an email email|View user's profile profileRight Button Spacer
Left Button SpacerReply to this message replyRight Button Spacer
 
Michael Fritchman
Michael Fritchman
Read 1231 times

Total Messages 1

Subject:Why BBM

i agree. BBM has the best format  but prizes compared to cost has a lot to be desired. ive been playing since 1991 prodigy too.

 


Posted: 26 Mar 2010 05:27 PM
Originally Posted: 26 Mar 2010 05:28 PM
Left Button SpacerSend user an email email|View user's profile profileRight Button Spacer
Left Button SpacerReply to this message replyRight Button Spacer
 
Jim O'Donnell
Jim O'Donnell
Read 1117 times

Total Messages 1

Subject:Why BBM

I think the key BBM attribute is the daily fix every junkie needs.

My opinion is Scoresheet offers the best game...batting orders vs LH and RH pitchers, hitters stats adjusted vs LH and RH pitching based on hitters real life ability to hit LH and RH pitching, ability to bunt, sacrifice, steal, set pitching rotations, decide when to pull SPers, relief pitcher rules, juggle rotation to face specific teams, defensive range counts, real life errors count...gives youuthe ability to truly manage a game.

Go with a private league and set your own rules...salary cap if you want, draft or auction, multiple year contracts, raises, penalties for cutting a player...anything and everything you want.  Gives you the ability to be a General Manager.

Down side is it is a weekly simulation that uses the previous weeks real stats.  Has it's plusses because you make your decisions before the weeks games, the MLB games get played for the week, then your results are simulated (on a batter to batter basis), so if you sit a player and he hits 4 HRs that week...too bad...you made a bad decision...those HRs are gone...not in a stat pool.  But it has that one big minus...how to get that daily fix every junkie needs.

So I do both.  BBM gives the daily fix this junkie needs....and Scoresheet gives the best high possible...just what every junkie needs.  


Posted: 02 Apr 2010 05:21 PM
Left Button SpacerSend user an email email|View user's profile profileRight Button Spacer
Left Button SpacerReply to this message replyRight Button Spacer
 
 
Start a new topic New Topic
 

 
go

Log In Options


Powered by WebBoard Powered by WebBoard 7
©2006 Akiva Corporation